Payton Scott Montague

Payton Scott Montague, 70, of St. Petersburg, Florida, passed away unexpectedly on August 1, 2026.

Born on May 8, 1956, in Newport, North Carolina, Payton lived a life marked by faith, compassion, humor, and an unwavering desire to help others. He was passionate about learning and followed his calling with determination throughout every season of his life.

Payton attended Florida State University, where he studied Musical Theatre, before earning a Master of Science in Mental Health and Marriage & Family Counseling from Stetson University. He spent 32 years with 3M Unitek before answering a deeper calling to become a mental health therapist. As a counselor through Lutheran Counseling Services in St. Petersburg, he devoted himself to walking alongside others with empathy, wisdom, and genuine care. He believed every person deserved to be heard, valued, and given hope.

His faith was the foundation of his life. A devoted member of Our Savior Lutheran Church in St. Petersburg, Payton loved the Lord and sought to reflect Christ’s love in the way he cared for those around him.

Outside of work, Payton was happiest surrounded by family. He loved being out on the water as captain of the family’s beloved “Mental Floss” boats, playing guitar, reading, enjoying a good movie or cigar, and, perhaps most famously, telling dad jokes that never failed to make everyone laugh-whether they wanted to or not. His quick wit, infectious sense of humor, and gift for entertaining brought joy to countless people.

Those who knew Payton will remember him as passionate, empathetic, and genuinely funny. He had a rare ability to make people feel seen, safe, and deeply loved. His hugs became legendary among those closest to him-a place of comfort, reassurance, and unconditional love. They are a gift his family will treasure forever.

Payton was preceded in death by his parents, Robert and Kathryn Montague; his brother Samuel Montague; and the many loved ones who welcomed him into eternity.

He is survived by his beloved wife, Pam Montague; his daughters, Lindsay Renninger and Vanessa (Mark) Watson; and his cherished grandchildren, Nathan Rennigner, Jacob Renninger, Eden Watson, Jace Watson, and Chance Watson, all of whom brought immeasurable joy to his life.

Although Payton was unable to fulfill his wish of donating after his passing, his family finds comfort in knowing that his legacy of generosity will continue through memorial gifts supporting mental health in our community. In lieu of flowers, memorial donations may be made in his memory to Lutheran Counseling Services. Through these gifts, his family hopes to continue his lifelong mission of caring for others.

“Well done, good and faithful servant.” – Matthew 25:23

Service information to follow

Thank you for honoring Payton Montague and the lives he impacted by supporting mental health.lutherancounselingservices.harnessgiving.org